Secure payment - Ships to all US states - $9.95 flat rate shipping

Curated Candy

by Daniel Levin

Curated Candy

Handsome Dan’s is a small shop but we pack a lot of candy in, from floor to ceiling. On our walls, you’ll find all types of candy from Gummies and Sours, to Vintage Candy Bars and Japanese Candy Making Kits.  And we stock a wide array of brands from old school favorites like Annabelle’s to well known Haribo and Trolli to local C. Howard’s. Stock switches around every few months and each store has it’s own inventory. If you’re looking for something specific, feel free to call first! Below is a list of just a fraction of what we offer:


Gummy Frogs, Worms, Peachy Penguins, Double Cherry, Strawberry, Jelly Whales, Apple Rings, Peach Rings, Gummy Bears, Techno Gummy Bears, Cola Bottles …

Curated Gummy Candy: Gummy Bears, Gummy Cola Bottles, Gummy Frogs, Gummy Funky Blobs, Gummy Peach Rings, Gummy Worms & Jelly Babies



Sour Watermelon Rind, Sour Patch Kids, Sour Belts, Sour Straws, Blue Raspberry Colas, Sour Cola Bottles, Warheads, Warhead Spray, Sour Gummy Bears, Sour Worms…

Curated Sour Candy: Sour Watermelon Rind, Sour Patch Kids, Sour Belts, Sour Straws, Blue Raspberry Colas, Sour Cola Bottles, Warheads, Warhead Spray, Sour Gummy Bears, Sour Worms


Hard Candy

Jawbreakers, Fireballs, Lemonheads, Sweetarts, Bottle Caps, Shockers, C Howards Violets, Crybabies…

Curated hard candy


SHOP IT HERE!!! Or come by our STORES...



Chocolate Rocks, Malt Balls, Chocolate Covered Blueberries, Chocolate Covered Espresso Beans, Chocolate Covered Cookie Dough,  Sea Salt Caramels, White and Milk Chocolate Gummy Bears, Chocolate Pretzels covered with Reese’s Pieces, Tiramisu Truffle, Chocolate Graham Cracker, Chocolate Cigars…


Salty Road Taffy, Mast Brothers Chocolate, Brooklyn Hard Candy, Nunu Chocolate, Liddabit Chocolate, Lucky Bird Walnut Brittle…



Bubble tape, Double Bubble, Big League Chew, C Howard Violet, Teaberry, Blackjack, Clove, Beemans, Gumballs, Double Bubble, Mini Chiclets…



Angry Birds Candy Toys, Pez, Hello Kitty Tins, Mustache Mints, PacMan Tins, Nintendo Tins, Fun Dip, Ring Pop, Pop Rocks, Giant Pixy Stix, Super Rope, Yard Stick Gum, Extra Large Whirly Lollipops, Wax Lips, Wax Mustache, Lunchboxes filled with Candy, Giant Smarties, Laffy Taffy, Giant Tootsie roll, Giant Gummy Bear, Gunmy Bear Keychain Lights, Gummy Bear Soap…



Red Wheels, Black Wheels, Crows, Licorice Pipes, Salt Licorice Coins, Selmiak, Salt Fish, Australian Red, Australian Black, Good and Plenty, Rockies…

Curated licorice candy: All sorts candy, red licorice, pastel licorace



We carry several varieties of taffy. First is our local favorite Salty Road with flavors like Sea Sal Caramel, Peppermint and Egg Nog. We also carry Fralinger’s Taffy and old school favorite Turkish Taffy in Chocolate, Vanilla, Banana, and Strawberry…

Candy Colors

We curate the finest candy from all colors and put it together in recycled paper bags and mason jars. We do all green candy, blue candy, black candy, white candy, red candy, pink candy, yellow candy and orange candy. 

Curated Blue Candy, Red Candy, Black Candy, Green Candy, Yellow Candy, Pink Candy, White Candy

We pride ourselves on our curated candy collection. Please call us at 917-965-2499, if you would like to know what we have currently in stock, or for special orders. We will try our best to find what you are looking for!


SHOP IT HERE!!! Or come by our STORES...

Get free taffy with your first order!

That's right. Just click the button below to find out how you can get FREE box of taffy with your first order:

Daniel Levin
Daniel Levin


Leave a comment

Sizing chart - M, L & XL Recycled Paper Bags & Mason Jars
Gallons Est. weight*
XL Half gallon 2.80-3.40 lbs
L Quart 1.40-1.70 lbs
M Pint 0.70-0.85 lbs
weight is estimated and excluded packaging and varies by candy type and mix